Mike Bell
Fisherman
Thomas F. Wilson
Fish #3 / Tough Fish #1 (voice)
Scarlett Johansson
Mindy (voice)
Jeffrey Tambor
King Neptune (voice)
Clancy Brown
Mr. Krabs (voice)
Alec Baldwin
Dennis (voice)
Cole S. McKay
Scruffy the Pirate
Jill Talley
Karen / Old Lady (voice)
Mageina Tovah
Usher
Dee Bradley Baker
Cop / Phil / Perch / Waiter / Attendant #1 / Various (voice)
Lori Alan
Pearl (voice)
Henry Kingi
Inky the Pirate
David Hasselhoff
David Hasselhoff
David Stifel
Cookie the Pirate
Bill Fagerbakke
Patrick Star / Fish #2 / Chum Customer / Local Fish (voice)
Sirena Irwin
Reporter / Driver / Ice Cream Lady (voice)
Carlos Alazraqui
King Neptune's Squire (voice)
Aaron Hendry
Tangles the Pirate / Cyclops Diver
Neil Ross
Cyclops (voice)
Rodger Bumpass
Squidward / Fish #4 (voice)
Stephen Hillenburg
Parrot (voice)
Derek Drymon
The Screamer / Fisherman (voice)
Tom Kenny
SpongeBob / Narrator / Gary / Various (voice)
Carolyn Lawrence
Sandy (voice)
Mary Jo Catlett
Mrs. Puff (voice)
Gino Montesinos
Tango the Pirate
Kristopher Logan
Squinty the Pirate
Todd Duffey
Concession Guy
Dylan Haggerty
Stitches the Pirate
Mr. Lawrence
Plankton / Fish #7 / Attendant #2 (voice)
Paul Zies
Upper Deck the Pirate (voice)
Tim Blaney
Singing Goofy Goober (voice)
Bart McCarthy
Captain Bart the Pirate
Joshua Seth
Prisoner (voice)
Tommy Schooler
Salty the Pirate