Jane Wyatt
Madge Harvey
Philip Coolidge
Jim Crossman
Lee J. Cobb
Chief Harold F. 'Robbie' Robinson
Frank Overton
Man in Mob Behind Courthouse
Karl Malden
Det. Lt. White
Arthur Kennedy
John Waldron
Taylor Holmes
T.M. Wade
Dana Andrews
State's Attorney Henry L. Harvey
Leona Roberts
Mrs. Crossman
Sam Levene
Morning Record's Reporter Dave Woods
Anthony Ross
Warren
Bert Freed
Herron, a Man in Alley Mob
Brian Keith
Man in Mob Behind Courthouse
Reed Hadley
Narrator (voice)
Arthur Miller
Line-Up Suspect
Ed Begley
Paul Harris
Robert Keith
'Mac' McCreery
Cara Williams
Irene Nelson
Wyrley Birch
Father George A. Lambert