Jack Palance
Torvald
Katy Jurado
Sara
Ivan Triesault
Anthony Quinn
Barabbas
Ernest Borgnine
Lucius
Arthur Kennedy
Pontius Pilate
Vittorio Gassman
Sahak
Silvana Mangano
Rachel
Douglas Fowley
Vasasio
Harry Andrews
Peter
Valentina Cortese
Julia
Sharon Tate
Patrician in Arena (uncredited)
Michael Gwynn
Lazarus
Fernando Hilbeck
Norman Wooland
Rufio
Paola Pitagora
Carlo Giustini
Officer (as Carlo Giutini)
Sal Borgese
Gladiator
Lucia Modugno
George Birt
John Stacy
Curt Lowens
Joe Robinson
Bearded Gladiator
Arnoldo Foà
Joseph of Arimathea
Marco Tulli
Friedrich von Ledebur
Officer (as Frederich Ledebur)
Massimo Righi
Gustavo De Nardo
Giovanni Di Benedetto
Officer (as Gianni Di Benedetto)
Paul Müller
Roger Browne
Natasha Lytess
Miranda Campa
Laurence Payne
Disciple
Gaetano Scala
Vera Drudi
Dale Cummings
Omero Capanna
Maria Zanoli
Beggar Woman
Roland Bartrop
Mimmo Poli
Dan Sturkie
Guido Celano
Scorpio
Enrico Glori
Man Pleading for Release of Prisoner
Emma Baron
Rina Franchetti
Rina Braido
Tavern Reveler
Burt Nelson
Amerigo Santarelli
Maria Marchi
Vladimiro Picciafuochi
Guard with Rufio
Robert Hall
Commander of Gladiators