Stephen McHattie
Andrew Borden
Gregg Henry
Director Attorney Hosea Knowlton
Christina Ricci
Lizzie Borden
Sara Botsford
Abby Morse Borden
Billy Campbell
Andrew Jennings
Clea DuVall
Emma Borden
John Maclaren
Reverend Buck
Shawn Doyle
Marshall Hilliard
Andrew Gillies
Judge Mason
John Dunsworth
Doctor Bowen
Brian Downey
Jury Foreman
Gary Levert
Judge Coughlin
Andrew Bush
Medical Examiner
Andrea Runge
Alice Russell
Glen Lefchak
Eli Bence
Brett Donahue
Marshal Fleet
Hannah Anderson
Bridget Sullivan