Dana Ashbrook
Gary
Mena Suvari
Jane
Debra Jo Rupp
Tracy
Eric Roberts
Mr. Campbell
Geoff Stults
Vince
Josh Hopkins
Kenny
Kristin Chenoweth
Mrs. Kemp
Joey Fatone
Delivery Guy
Jonathan Silverman
Tom
Jennifer Finnigan
Stephanie
Kenan Thompson
Mitch
Josh Cooke
Kendrick
Nadia Dajani
Tom Papa
Tom DeNucci
Reno
David Gere
Gay Man #3
Madeline Merritt
Mrs. Havacamp
Chad Verdi Jr.
Gay Clubgoer #3
Gary Wolfenden
Club Patron (uncredited)
Fred Sullivan
Gay Man #5
Pauly Popolizio
Cool Guy in Bar (uncredited)