Michael Badalucco
Derek
Beth Grant
Evelyn
Vanessa Evigan
Kelly
Lacey Chabert
Becky
Tony Hale
Ben
Amy Aquino
Detective Curwen
Joe Nuñez
Mr. Mather
Alexandra Paul
Roxana
Philip Winchester
Marcus
Shanna Collins
Jennifer
Kelly Overton
Ann
Kathryn Fiore
Lisa
Christopher Darga
Officer Etling
Bellamy Young
Olivia
Bunny Levine
Rachel
Kevin Kilner
Greg
Patrick Labyorteaux
Rob
Tim Draxl
Justin
Abigail Spencer
Gwen
Aidan Mitchell
Young Marcus
Kirsten Vangsness
Madge
Allan Wasserman
Dr. Schwarz
Cassie Fliegel
Surprise Party Ex-Girlfriend
Syr Law
Babysitter
Julia Faye West
Club Patron (uncredited)
Joy Bisco
Exotic Woman
Larry Clarke
Officer Knachel
Jade Tailor
Babysitter
Brenda Schmid
Babysitter
Robert Joseph
Officer Cooley