Jay Duplass
Professor Notkin (uncredited)
Logan Miller
Sam
Amy Landecker
Mom
Nick Saso
Mason Birch
Mallory Low
Caroline
Dylan Gelula
Maggie Hill
Abby Quinn
Georgia
Olivia Scott Welch
Jess
Adan Rocha
Scott
Joy Sunday
Sophia
Ayo Edebiri
Emily (uncredited)
Tre Hall
Garrett
Cooper Raiff
Alex Malmquist
Tessa Hope Slovis
Not Maggie
Juan Wood
Charlie
Alina Patra
Julia
Chinedu Unaka
Timothy
Wyatt Whipple
Seb