Tom McGowan
Ed Jordan
Aaron Tveit
James Galant
Victoria Clark
Gabriella Galant
Jerry Kernion
Driver
Laura Osnes
Anna Jordan
Ian Lyons
Musician
J.P. Giuliotti
Donny's Clerk
Chengusoyane Kargbo
Nurse
Kerry McGann
Local Woman Carrie
Geraldine Leer
Diane
Josiah Harvey
Ball Guest
Krystal Joy Brown
Sarah Melnick
Bradley Rose
Christopher Brooks
Frances McGarry
Mrs. Maitlin
Will Child
Santa
Derrick Davis
MC
Dana Wine
Extra (uncredited)