Michael Benyaer
Marty
Rachel Dratch
Marga Clüsterfünke
David Milchard
Holly's Dad
Maya Rudolph
Shania Gary (Angel)
Christine Lippa
Canadian-Sounding Mayor
Aaron Douglas
Windmere
Ana Gasteyer
Hildy Clüsterfünke
Ryan McPartlin
Chancington Winterthorpe V
Nils Hognestad
Percy Sleigh
Cheyenne Jackson
Frank Clüsterfünke
Kazumi Evans
Bestie
Pippa Mackie
Waiter (Cocoa Kiosk)
Ken Godmere
Old Timey Doctor
Vella Lovell
Holly Jenkins
Duane Keogh
Postman Steve
Sharon Crandall
May
Brendan Riggs
New York Man
Connor O'Mahony
Redhead Kid
Kwasi Thomas
Jackie
Aiyanna Miorin
Little Holly
Daylin Willis
Kenny (Assistant)
Kerën Burkett
Holly's Mom
Amanda Huxtable
Redhead Mom
Alia Domino
No-Brow Janet